General plans?

Well I already sent a PM saying I think Dohnut should be taken out at some point, he's pretty good at the mafia from the last thread imo. There's a chance he might get an early protection off it, though.


What I am thinking on an unrelated note, we're clearly a flying mafia, would it be worth trying to find close approximations to our pokemans and style it as another pokemon? Obv not do it too soon, in case a writeup trips us up, but when it comes to a questioning, people might put a flying mafia together quickly(though maybe a Danny style double bluff will work fine :p).

My role states that if I target someone to kill and they are protected then I end up killing the protector. So I think it's a good idea that you choose me for the nightkills?

I think they'll find out it's a flying mafia sooner or later, so I guess the best way is to pretend to be a "flyer" that isn't a flying type, eg Venomoth.

CoolnessBears
Dannyboy-the-Dane
dan-likes-trees
Dyson
Ellmeister
Gizmo
Marcamillian
MoogleViper
Mundi
Nintendohnut
Paj Meen Ah
Raining_again
Tales
Tellyn

Player list minus us. Makes it easier to select targets.

I'm thinking of targeting Mundi, that ok?

Also, is someone/Rummy going to send it all as one or separate?

I'm not really sure how to target. I'll let the first night run and see who starts to complain in the morning.

Starly wrote:My role states that if I target someone to kill and they are protected then I end up killing the protector. So I think it's a good idea that you choose me for the nightkills?.

Unless we need to both silence and kill someone in the same night then it seems like a good idea.

I know I'm 'the don' but I think once we're agreed, we should let Cube send in the collective decision. He's got more mafia experience than me :p

The biggest giveaway judging by ReZ's lightlife writeups was sizes, and colours, so if we can find potential approximations in the event of coming up with a lie, it could give any of us when suspected a few more nights. I wouldn't say to pre-emptively say what pokemon we are, in case a writeup then later gives us away, but...iono.

Also, kinda unrelated and I hope it won't cause much problem, but I happen to see Marcamillian alot IRL(in fact just spent the day with him) so I run a risk of giving anything away if he asks me about it, but I have informed him not to talk about the game outside the game.

Hoothoot wrote:I'm not really sure how to target. I'll let the first night run and see who starts to complain in the morning.

I'm pretty sure it's just when the night phase begins, we send in a PM to ReZ saying who is being targeted, and by which one of us.

I ment i'm not really sure who to target.

Of course I know how to target people

If someone tracks me it says I targeted nobody. So there's pretty much no risk in me targeting someone.

Interesting. Marcamillian is annoying me, whilst not talking about the mafia, general mafia conversation comes up. It might be working to my advantage but makes me feel like I'm cheating.

Anyway, Raining's brought up a double vote, cast suspicion on such a power(as did happen to me last game) yet not named a person. Later named Dannyboy, so I assume her info was good but maybe she's trying to goad a mafia overreaction? Iono. Either way, sets Danny as a potential target if he shows poor reasoning? As a town vote/lynching, that is.

I'm liking Gizmo's response, that is a beautiful thing to jump on. We can lynch/push for lynch on Ell(which I'll vote on in a bit, so as not to jump too quickly) and then when it is possibly wrong, we can jump on Gizmo as some sort of liar, so good times there! As a town vote/lynchings again, that is.

If we kill off other suspects, will it then become reverse obvious that it's not them, or will the other killings just look random? Well, I think as I type and realise if we lynch other people, it just makes them look mafia. I'm not even sure why I'm still typing, I'm going to stop and go to sleep. Sorry. Drinklol.

I say we kill Raining tonight as she's an investigator. However, I don't think that Rummy should use his double vote.

I think the suspicious would fade on Gizmo during the next day as we'll find out that he just get results the wrong way round (i.e. if he finds out anyone is good, they will then be evil) and therefore he will be a powerful investigator. He can go during night three.

Think I might just target a random townie to silence. Although they will probably say that they were silenced once the next night was over. Might as well take a chance though.

My double vote is now likely to become very obvious if I use it, because to use it I have to specifically put it in a different colour, people will notice it straight away so it's going to have to be saved for later. Danny's been exposed as having one, and if it comes out that he's town, it'll be hard to argue that I am too without there being doubts in at least some minds.

As for the vote to kill raining, I'm down with that, pesky investigators can pose a problem! I haven't check the thread since this morning, I saw alot of posts earlier that I didn't have time to read through, so I'll post again once I have.

I've asked ReZ the following question:

andom question about MadDog as there is a possible conundrum: MadDog can't be tracked.

Here is the situation.

MadDog targets Player A

Player B gets information on who targets Player A.

Will Player B know that MadDog targeted Player A?

If the answer is "Player B gets no info" then we have a plan for Moogle and Ell.

We just have to decide if Gizmo or these are more important.

Why did everyone(well, I noticed Cube and MadDog) withdraw on Ell? Him and Moogle might pose a large problem to us now, with one lynched the other was an easy kill, and Gizmo would have been an easy scapegoat with it!

I haven't had much time to keep up with the thread, and won't til monday, so this post may be misinformed. I was meant to post this earlier while at work but I forgot my password to here lol, so I could only read but not post.

Stumbled across this, may be handy if writeups continue by colour and we want to lie to eliminate a flying mafia, like the electric mafia, theory. Of course, we should confer first, so as not to have two with the same lie

http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/List_of_Pokémon_by_color

We wasn't going to get the majority, so it was pointless keeping my vote up.

On night 1 I found that Mundi targeted nobody, and night 2 Dyson targeted nobody.

Just saying that nobody has targetted me yet, or at least I don't think so, as I'm supposed to find out who they are if they do, and ReZ hasn't told me anything. I've just thought I could have earlier pounced on Danny for having a double vote by pointing out I have one too, and so he must be evil cos I'm (obviously) good lol. Bit late for that now, reckon it wouldn't make me look good if I tried it now

So there's...4 of us left now? Which means we need to get another 3 of the town killed to win the game, whilst managing to stay alive at the same time? Is that right?

I'll target Tales.